Solr4 Search return 0 match after upgrade from 5.0.3+Solr4 to 5.2.5+Solr4 with 5.0.3's Solr4 index backup restored

Issue:

Solr4 Search return 0 match after upgrade from 5.0.3+Solr4 to 5.2.5+Solr4 with 5.0.3's Solr4 index backup restored into 5.2.5's Solr4. 

Step to Reproduce 
1) Install 5.0.3.5+Solr4
2) import customer's content model.
3) create content to match the model and search query programmatically using js script: 

4) verify the afts search, with query:  See Search Query below

returns the expected result. 

5) upgrade the repository to 5.2.5 + Solr4
6) copy the /alf_data/solr/index from 5.0.3.5 to 5.2.5
7) restart and test the search from step4, it will return 0 match now. 

Things tried and observed so far: 

1. A full reindex on upgraded 5.2.5+Solr4 instance does not fix the issue. 
2. An metadata update which trigger metadata reindex does not fix the issue. 
3. Issue not reproduce if creating a brand new node with same properties in upgraded 5.2.5+Solr4 instance.