[MNT-20857] [APS] Need option to 'Open As New' or 'Save as New' for forms/subprocesses in process editor Created: 21-Aug-19  Updated: 27-Jan-20  Resolved: 14-Jan-20

Status: Closed
Project: Service Packs and Hot Fixes
Component/s: APS Kickstart/Studio
Affects Version/s: Alfresco Process Services 1.9.0.5
Fix Version/s: None

Type: Service Pack Request
Reporter: Jennie Soria [X] (Inactive) Assignee: Closed Issues
Resolution: Won't Fix Votes: 0
Labels: None
Remaining Estimate: Not Specified
Time Spent: Not Specified
Original Estimate: Not Specified
Environment:

APS


Attachments: PNG File defaultSaveForm.png     PNG File defaultSaveProcess.png     PNG File openform.png     PNG File openformAsNew.png     PNG File saveAsNewProcess.png     PNG File saveAsNewSaveForm.png    
Issue Links:
Cloners
Related
relates to MNT-21280 Error when duplicating processes with... Closed
Bug Priority:
Category 4
ACT Numbers:

00993281


 Description   

Summary

The export of a process and import will not change anything defined in the export bpmn20.xml. The form-referenced-id will be the same (and subprocess ids will be the same), the form itself will be the same.

If you edit the form it will affect all other models that are referencing that from id. This is to be expected as the forms by default are intended to be shareable, but it is not obvious to the editor that is the case. This will cause issues with pre-existing processes using that form or the process the new one was cloned from.

Ideally, there should be an option when editing a form to 'Open as new' or when closing after editing to "save as new".

The optional button should automatically save the form as a new form with new id.

Current Save Form Suggested Save Form

OR

Current Open Form Suggested Open Form

For Subprocesses same concept..Current Save Model (in case of subprocesses):

current suggested

Add 'Save as New', on click popup confirms 'You will be creating new form id'
Add 'Save', on click popup confirms 'You will be updating existing form, this will impact all references using it'

This is probably the most realistic editorial improvement request versus assuming all customers want a new form versus update existing form or processes referenced.

Options/workaround:

  • form must be create 'new' >> cons: complex forms, human errors
  • form in the form tab (if the form is NOT embedded) cloned, then remember in process where form is and reselect
  • form if embedded, you need to unembbed it, exit process, go to form tab, clone it, go back to process, and select the new cloned form, then embed and save process again

Workaround cons: multiple steps in and out of process editor, if process is complex and long and there are multiple forms in the process this is inefficient, human errors risk increases significantly, excessive saving and versions(proc) pile up in repository causing performance problems

Business Case

Customer needs to replicate the main processs as is, then edit the embedded forms to fit the use of the new copy. This also includes the subprocess (collapsed or not that are referenced). It is non-intuitive to them that when they edit the embedded form that it is not tied to the current process but is a shared form across many. This results in breaking the design of the other processes.



 Comments   
Comment by Mark Howarth [ 02-Dec-19 ]

Assigning to Mark Howarth as PM for APS.

Generated at Mon Jul 13 20:26:04 BST 2020 using JIRA 7.6.3#76005-sha1:8a4e38d34af948780dbf52044e7aafb13a7cae58.